The Amateur Strategist

This book explores how the everyday person reasons about nuclear strategy. James DeNardo’s data reveals surprising patterns of thinking on basic issues from SDI, arms control, and proliferation to the end of the Cold War. The book describes a fascinating cast of players, including ‘Nice Hawks’ like Ronald Reagan, who wanted to give SDI to the Russians, and the ‘NIFFs,’ whose procurement rule, expressed simply, was: ‘If they have it, we don’t want it, but they don’t have it, we should get it.’ To explain his remarkable evidence, Professor DeNardo presents an innovative theory of intuitive deterrence reasoning. He then confronts the theory with data from professional nuclear strategists. His discovery that the amateur’s strategic reasoning defies all conventional theories lays the groundwork for a new understanding of national security politics. His demonstration that professional strategists reason like novices - that we are all Amateur Strategists - challenges the intellectual foundations of modern deterrence theory, public opinion studies, and game theory.